官术网_书友最值得收藏!

第99章

  • TOPICS
  • Aristotle
  • 259字
  • 2016-01-18 18:41:05

A premiss in reasoning always either is one of the constituent elements in the reasoning, or else goes to establish one of these:

(and you can always tell when it is secured in order to establish something else by the fact of a number of similar questions being put: for as a rule people secure their universal by means either of induction or of likeness):-accordingly the particular propositions should all be admitted, if they are true and generally held. On the other hand, against the universal one should try to bring some negative instance; for to bring the argument to a standstill without a negative instance, either real or apparent, shows ill-temper. If, then, a man refuses to grant the universal when supported by many instances, although he has no negative instance to show, he obviously shows ill-temper. If, moreover, he cannot even attempt a counter-proof that it is not true, far more likely is he to be thought ill-tempered-although even counter-proof is not enough: for we often hear arguments that are contrary to common opinions, whose solution is yet difficult, e.g. the argument of Zeno that it is impossible to move or to traverse the stadium;-but still, this is no reason for omitting to assert the opposites of these views. If, then, a man refuses to admit the proposition without having either a negative instance or some counter-argument to bring against it, clearly he is ill-tempered: for ill-temper in argument consists in answering in ways other than the above, so as to wreck the reasoning.

主站蜘蛛池模板: 石狮市| 长白| 上虞市| 建德市| 东乡县| 三台县| 巴林右旗| 合山市| 江达县| 舞钢市| 巨野县| 溆浦县| 茂名市| 蕲春县| 万州区| 象山县| 金华市| 庄河市| 武功县| 阳西县| 阿拉善右旗| 开阳县| 阳西县| 巨鹿县| 三河市| 沂南县| 温宿县| 东阿县| 辽阳市| 井研县| 峨边| 沅江市| 望都县| 桑日县| 普陀区| 资兴市| 民勤县| 行唐县| 依兰县| 香港| 芒康县|