官术网_书友最值得收藏!

第88章

  • TOPICS
  • Aristotle
  • 399字
  • 2016-01-18 18:41:05

That it is more difficult to establish than to overthrow a definition, is obvious from considerations presently to be urged.

For to see for oneself, and to secure from those whom one is questioning, an admission of premisses of this sort is no simple matter, e.g. that of the elements of the definition rendered the one is genus and the other differentia, and that only the genus and differentiae are predicated in the category of essence. Yet without these premisses it is impossible to reason to a definition; for if any other things as well are predicated of the thing in the category of essence, there is no telling whether the formula stated or some other one is its definition, for a definition is an expression indicating the essence of a thing. The point is clear also from the following: It is easier to draw one conclusion than many. Now in demolishing a definition it is sufficient to argue against one point only (for if we have overthrown any single point whatsoever, we shall have demolished the definition); whereas in establishing a definition, one is bound to bring people to the view that everything contained in the definition is attributable. Moreover, in establishing a case, the reasoning brought forward must be universal: for the definition put forward must be predicated of everything of which the term is predicated, and must moreover be convertible, if the definition rendered is to be peculiar to the subject. In overthrowing a view, on the other hand, there is no longer any necessity to show one's point universally: for it is enough to show that the formula is untrue of any one of the things embraced under the term.

Further, even supposing it should be necessary to overthrow something by a universal proposition, not even so is there any need to prove the converse of the proposition in the process of overthrowing the definition. For merely to show that the definition fails to be predicated of every one of the things of which the term is predicated, is enough to overthrow it universally: and there is no need to prove the converse of this in order to show that the term is predicated of things of which the expression is not predicated. Moreover, even if it applies to everything embraced under the term, but not to it alone, the definition is thereby demolished.

主站蜘蛛池模板: 安岳县| 公主岭市| 阆中市| 耿马| 崇左市| 格尔木市| 霍州市| 宜昌市| 绿春县| 宣武区| 大兴区| 洛宁县| 什邡市| 砚山县| 张北县| 托克托县| 周口市| 沁源县| 镇江市| 五河县| 肥东县| 阿荣旗| 辉县市| 苏尼特左旗| 长汀县| 惠安县| 上林县| 藁城市| 社旗县| 元江| 汝城县| 建昌县| 小金县| 东港市| 沂水县| 博湖县| 南通市| 武胜县| 天镇县| 出国| 铜山县|